Bay Shore Real Estate

Welcome to Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore, NY is a charming and growing community located on the South Shore of Long Island. With its beautiful natural scenery, excellent schools, and thriving downtown area, Bay Shore is an ideal place for families and professionals to call home. If you're considering buying or renting a property in Bay Shore, here are some of the reasons why it's an excellent choice. Firstly, Bay Shore is surrounded by beautiful parks and nature preserves, offering ample opportunities for outdoor recreation, such as hiking, fishing, and bird-watching. The village also operates several parks, including the Captree State Park, which features a playground, picnic areas, and stunning views of the Great South Bay. Secondly, Bay Shore is home to a thriving downtown area, with a variety of shops, restaurants, and other local businesses. The village also hosts several events throughout the year, such as the annual Bay Shore Art Walk, which brings the community together with local artists and musicians. Thirdly, the schools in Bay Shore are well-regarded, with a focus on student success and academic excellence. The Bay Shore Union Free School District consistently ranks among the top school districts in New York, with high graduation rates and SAT scores. Finally, Bay Shore is conveniently located just minutes away from major highways, making it easy to commute to nearby cities like New York City, which is just a short train ride away. With its beautiful parks, thriving downtown, excellent schools, and convenient location, Bay Shore, NY is the perfect place for families and professionals to build a future.

Bay Shore - Town vs. County Stats

Avg Price in Bay Shore: $608,400 / County Avg $1,314,100


Avg Taxes in Bay Shore: $11,400 / County Avg $12,900


Avg Sq. Ft. in Bay Shore: 10,106 / County Avg 15,021


Avg Price per/sqft in Bay Shore:$60 / County Avg $87


Avg Walkscore in Bay Shore: 44 / County Avg 33


Avg Year Built in Bay Shore: 1960 / County Avg 1973


Avg Days on Website in Bay Shore: 96 / County Avg 108


Bay Shore Real Estate Market Health

New Listings
Short Sales
Neighborhoods in Bay Shore NY
Newbrook Gardens